Hello Ali,
I don't come into the Seren's Synapse hall at MM very often because I write/critique little if any free verse pieces. I couldn't help noticing the exchange with Daniel here and won't add anything on this thread which Daniel hasn't covered pertaining to form poetry.
I did notice you posted your comment about my not replying to your
Short Rondeau about this and that at around 7:00 am this morning. I posted a reply to your "Short Rondeau" over in Karnak at 9:01 yesterday pertaining to the "tiny nits" I mentioned. As I said there, you are free to write anything you wish and hope you did not take umbrage with what I said. Apparently you did! My "erroneous statement" pertaining to the two tiny errors in your post has been blown way out of proportion. I did offer a statement regarding the tetrameter comment and if you had read my reply from yesterday before going of on me in another forum this morning, you would have seen that explanation.
Sorry you feel this is an "Elitist Site". I don't and never have found it to be of that ilk. It is, to me, one of the few that will give honest and concise critique to the depth the writer requests. All such critique is given in a "take-or-toss" vein and any decision for change is entirely up to the writer.
I do hope you will stay around and find out the "truth" about MM and the few denizens left here. We are here to help!
Larry