Hi Larry,
Good to see you!!! It's been a while. Please do not take offense at my comment to Sam regarding the Cinquain - I see now what parts you are comparing it to - however, there is so much more to a Cinquain besides the Params of rhyme scheme, that I actually felt there was many other forms that it might have been a variant on.
I suppose my whole point to that comment was to give Sam a thumbs up that so far, the form, although simular is new to me!
I use to be a Cinquain Queen, in my earlier days. I too, for simular reasons as your own, don't find them that exciting - actually they are quite hard to create one that is in the TRUE sense of a Cinquain. I however, use them for filler poems in manuscripts... or links from one poem into another where there is a relationship but fully stand alone poems.
I also LOVE the Rictameters. I think they offer a little more for the poet to dabble with, however they are my filler poems as well.
I truly understand about variations on poems. I myself, created the Quatrain Refrain (named by Lori) and although there are a few simular forms, I haven't come across anything exact etiher.
Again, please accept my apology if you had taken it personal. It wasn't meant in that way, merely a way for me to give support to his desire to expand in his poetic acheievements.
So good to see you ... Miss your poetry as always ... as I am a meter woMan myself!
Best Wishes, Liz