Hi Jackie!
QUOTE
Hi Cathy,
Thanks for the wonderful feedback. You have given me much to think about and I'll be using most of your suggestions. I was pretty new to poetry when I wrote this but decided to place it as is for better feedback.
I have some pieces like that, I just haven't taken the time to go back to them. lolQUOTE
QUOTE
the {gift}[joy] of laughter Sometimes people don't like to use the same word twice and I didn't know if you were aware you had. This would be a way to avoid that if you wanted to.
I agree. Thanks for pointing it out. Being dyslexic I don't always catch these, especially in my own work.
I didn't realize. You certainly can't tell! *smiles* I know some don't mind repeating words like this and then there some have been taught it's a no-no. I kinda straddle the fence on this one cause sometimes you can't help it or it just feels right. QUOTE
QUOTE
{lighting}[kindling] fires of
lust and love
his words affect {us} 'effective' instead of 'affect'?
{and} leave us spellbound
I like both of these suggestions
Cool!
QUOTE
QUOTE
The Poet violet
sings of serenity
sharing peaceful moments
{with} gentle words
remind{ing} us of God's love
{and} guidance through the storms
{the} language of hope
{that} lifts us from despair
I see where you are going with suggestions such as these. Sometimes I can write very cryptic poems but at others I feel pulled to more complete sentences (though not totally constructed as such). After reading your notes I am falling somewhere in the middle on this piece. I will most likely use a good share of your suggestions but leave some lines as they are. I appreciate the viewpoint though.
The poem is yours and must remain so. Do what your heart tells you to do. In the end only you know how you want it to come across and how best to accomplish that. *smiles* QUOTE
One suggestion, if I may. Being dyslexic and a very visual person, I had a little trouble noting your suggestions quickly. Though not necessary it would be helpful if you made them bold. Just a thought to help me. Not everyone has that difficulty.
Oh, I'm so sorry you had trouble figuring out my scribbles. I used to do them all in bold and I couldn't tell you why I stopped but I will remember that from now on. QUOTE
QUOTE
seeking sympathy for {his} suffering Would omitting 'his' make it sound like he is writing about others suffering, not just his own?
I can understand your thoughts but it was my intent to point out the selfish act in such a poet. (admittedly I have been a green poet at times) I wanted to keep it more personal in that way.
I see your point! In that case, I withdraw my suggestion! lol QUOTE
QUOTE
anger revealed when {he feels} threatened
But I do like this suggestion.
QUOTE
QUOTE
The Poet pink
plays innocen[ce]{tly}
{bringing back}[seeking] memories
of youthful folly
childlike tones {bring joy}
{to} transcend time
how we love {those moments}
to feel young again
I think I prefer innocently but do like seeking better and the rest of your suggestions here.
That's ok ... it was just a thought! *smiles* QUOTE
QUOTE
speaks with pride
{as he} teaches us valued lessons
I think "teaching us" might suit me. I think I'll be reworking the rest of this stanza.
That works too ...QUOTE
QUOTE
into love's canvas of silk 'silk canvas'
He speaks of longing
and hearts {filled to the} brim[ming]
of {those} moments most precious
{where} life truly begins
I like 'silk canvas' and brimming.
*smiles*QUOTE
QUOTE
{for} he is all colors held within
drawing on each
as he {so} desires
This makes sense. I have a tendency to wander into speaking forsoothly, especially back when I wrote this and still heavy into the medieval genre'.
I just didn't see it as necessary. A matter of preference most likely! lolQUOTE
QUOTE
So many {colors}[shades] upon the pallet
as authors we appreciate {this tool}
{for} it releases the creativity within
{and} the essence of our souls
I like these suggestions.
Cool!
QUOTE
QUOTE
I love the concept of this poem no matter what. One other thought ... each verse begins 'The Poet "color"'. What about dropping 'The' and just using 'Poet Blue' for example?
I'm so glad you liked the poem as a whole. Will have to think about this suggestion more as having 'The' just seems better for me. But I could be wrong.
Wrong? No ... as a writer it's what we choose to think sounds best for our purpose. All of my comments are based on my opinion only ... I don't see right or wrong when I write or when I crit. It's what YOU think that counts! I just thought it might personalize each 'color' or 'poet', make it sound like you were referring to a person rather than a specific color maybe? Does that make any sense? lolQUOTE
Thank you for all the time spent doing such a detailed review. It has been most helpful. Hopefully I can do some editing and repost sometime soon.
You are most welcome! I look forward to seeing what you do with it! And thanks for posting, I love the direction you took with it in describing the different outlooks from an artist's POV. Let me know when you post your revision!
CathyHey! My quotes didn't work either! LOL