Dear 2B,
You worry about your first crit, and Nina has welcomed it.
May I just add, as a very experienced critter (so quantity is there, quality is another matter lol), that I would have been proud to write this crit, you are already a pro !
It is so easy to crit and reduce or destroy - you have NOT done this, you have offered alt views and ideas. When I crit I try to help bring out the facets of an almost-brilliant diamond, and you have done this here.
Summating it all at the end is something I mostly do too, because it can become rather bitty while cutting and honing, so the summary offers a clearer view, and makes it easy for the poem's creator to see your thoughts clearly and globally.
Well done, more power to your elbow (needed for scything ! lol)
Love Alan
|